Thursday, April 3, 2014

Herbicide safety on microclover: Results from University Park

by Peter Landschoot, Dept. of Plant Science, Penn State


As the use of microclover in lawns gains interest among homeowners, questions will surface on how this species responds to routine lawn care practices such as mowing, fertilization, and weed control. Weed control practices are of particular concern due to the widespread use of herbicides that may injure microclover. A recent study by McCurdy et al. (2012) at Auburn University revealed that several common herbicides used in lawns effectively control clover species, including atrazine, dicamba, clopyralid, 2,4-D, triclopyr, metsulfuron, and trifloxysulfuron. However, these authors found that 2,4-DB, imazethapyr, and bentazon did not cause significant injury to clover, and suggested they may be suitable for weed control in scenarios where clover is a desirable species. Information is needed on the tolerance of microclover cultivars to broadleaf and annual grass herbicides used to control lawn weeds in the Chesapeake Bay watershed.

An experiment designed to examine tolerance of microclover to different broadleaf and annual grass herbicides was initiated at the J. Valentine Turfgrass Research Center in University Park, PA during the summer of 2012.  The experiment area was seeded on 7 June with a mixture of “Faith” tall fescue at 8 lb/1000 ft2 and “Pirouette” microclover (2 lb/1000 ft2) using a drop spreader. The tall fescue/microclover stand was mowed several times before the first herbicide treatments were applied. 
Fig. 1. Seeding Pirouette microclover into experiment area.  

Treatments included three postemergence broadleaf herbicides [Weedar 2,4-D Amine (3.8L); Aceto 2,4-DB Amine (2.0L); and Rhomene MCPA (3.7L)] applied at two or three different rates on September 6, 2012 and September 8, 2013 (Table 1).  Also, five preemergence herbicides [Gallery 75DF (isoxaben) applied at three different rates; Pendulum 60WDG (pendimethalin); Barricade 65WG (prodiamine); Dimension 1.0EC (dithiopyr); and Balan 2.5G (benefin)]; and one postemergence nutsedge herbicide [Basagran T/O 4.0L (bentazon)] were applied on May 7, 2013 (Table 2). 

All treatments were applied using a backpack sprayer at 40 psi with a dilution rate equivalent to 1 gallon water/1000 ft2. The experimental design was a randomized complete block design, and each treatment was replicated three times. Plot size was 30 ft2. 

Criteria for evaluating herbicide tolerance included visual ratings of foliar injury using a scale of 0-10, with 0 indicating no injury, and 10 representing complete desiccation of clover.  After the final injury rating was taken during the 2012 and 2013 experiments, visual assessments of percent clover cover were made.

Results
Late summer applications of 2,4-D amine at 2 and 3 pt/A caused noticeable injury and reduced cover of microclover when compared to the untreated control in 2012 and 2013. Injury from the 3 pt/A treatment was more severe than the 2 pt/A treatment in both years, resulting in an approximate 50% reduction in microclover ground cover in 2012 and 20% reduction in 2013. The 2 pt/A treatment resulted in about 20% less microclover relative to the control in 2012, and a 15% reduction in 2013, 3-4 weeks after treatment. The 2,4-DB treatments (2 pt/A, 4 pt/A, and 6 pt/A) did not produce visible foliar injury in 2012 or 2013, but the 6 pt/A treatment resulted in a slight reduction (8%) of microclover cover in 2012 compared to the control 1 month after treatment. No reduction in cover was observed with any 2,4-DB treatment in 2013. 

Fig. 2. Thinning of microclover in plot (on right) treated with 2,4-D.

No significant visible injury to microclover foliage was observed with the 0.5 and 1.0 pt/A rates of MCPA in 2012.  However, a slight reduction (8%) in microclover cover was detected with the 0.5 pt/A treatment in 2012.  In 2013 the 1.0 pt/A treatment showed some minor foliar discoloration following the late summer application.  Neither of the MCPA treatments resulted in microclover cover reductions in 2013.

Although some significant reductions of microclover were observed with 2,4-D applications in both years, the clover fully recovered during the spring of the following year. 
Table 1. Influence of herbicide treatments on Pirouette microclover following applications on September 6, 2012 and September 8, 2013 at the J. Valentine Turfgrass Research Center in University Park, PA.

Clover
% Clover
Clover
% Clover
Product
Injury§
Cover
Injury
Cover
Treatments
 Rate
9/21/2012
10/7/2012
9/16/2013
9/30/2013
2,4-D Amine (3.8L)
2 pt/A
3.7 b¥
72 c
4.0 b
81 b
2,4-D Amine (3.8L)
3 pt/A
6.7 a
45 d
6.3 a
75 b
2,4-DB Amine (2.0L)
2 pt/A
0 c
92 ab
0 d
97 a
2,4-DB Amine (2.0L)
4 pt/A
0 c
85 ab
0 d
97 a
2,4-DB Amine (2.0L)
6 pt/A
0.3 c
83 b
0 d
95 a
MCPA (3.7L)
0.5 pt/A
0.7 c
83 b
0 d
97 a
MCPA (3.7L)
1 pt/A
0.7 c
87 ab
1.0 c
95 a
Control
0 c
91 a
0 d
98 a
§Foliar injury visually assessed using a scale of 0-10, with 0 indicating no injury, and 10 representing complete desiccation of clover. 
¥Data means within the same column and followed by the same letter are not significantly different as determined by Fisher’s Protected Least Significant Difference test at P=0.05.
 
None of the preemergence annual grass herbicides used in the spring 2013 trial (Pendulum 60WDG, Barricade 65WG, Dimension 1.0EC, and Balan2.5 G) resulted in any visible injury or thinning of microclover.  However, all three rates of Gallery 75DF showed considerable injury, leading to thinning of the stand.  The only postemergence nutsedge herbicide used in the 2013 spring trial (Basagran T/O) did not produce visible injury symptoms or thinning. 

Based on results of the spring 2013 trial, Gallery 75DF should not be used in stands of microclover.  This trial will be repeated in 2014. 

Table 2. Influence of preemergence herbicide treatments and one postemergence herbicide (Basagran) on Pirouette microclover following applications on May 7, 2013 at the J. Valentine Turfgrass Research Center in University Park, PA.

Product
Injury§
Injury
Treatments
Rate
5/14/2013
17-May-13
Gallery 75DF
0.66 lb/A
2.0 ab¥
5.3 ab
Gallery 75DF
1.00 lb/A
2.3 ab
4.3 ab
Gallery 75DF
1.33 lb/A
3.7 a
5.3 a
Basagran T/O (4.0L)
2 pt/A
0 c
0 c
Pendulum 60WDG
3.4 lb/A
0 c
0 c
Barricade 65WG
1 lb/A
0 c
0 c
Dimension 1.0EC
2 qt/A
0 c
0 c
Balan 2.5G
60 lb/A
0 c
0 c
Control
0 c
0 c
§Foliar injury visually assessed using a scale of 0-10, with 0 indicating no injury, and 10 representing complete desiccation of clover. 
¥Data means within the same column and followed by the same letter are not significantly different as determined by Fisher’s Protected Least Significant Difference test at P=0.05.
 
References:


McCurdy, J.D., J.S. McElroy , and M.L. Flessner. 2013. Differential response of four Trifolium species to common broadleaf herbicides: Implications for mixed grass-legume swards. Weed Technology, 27(1):123-128.

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Runoff from Simulated Home Lawns: 2013 Data


Residential development where stormwater is being monitored




Simulated home lawn plots


Interpreting residential development stormwater data is fraught with difficulties when the goal is to evaluate the effectiveness of individual stormwater management practices. In such settings the combined effects of topography, surface type (i.e. pervious and impervious), building location, and the use of retention and conveyance structures make it difficult to isolate the effectiveness of specific practices in reducing flow during a storm event.  Research plots, on the other hand, offer the opportunity to evaluate the potential effectiveness of individual, or a small subset of practices, on reducing stormwater runoff.
In May of 2013 we began to measure runoff losses from 2400 square foot plots consisting of either a well-fertilized tall fescue lawn, or an unfertilized lawn comprised of tall fescue and microclover. The latter lawn was creating using a tall fescue seed mixture containing 5% by weight microclover at establishment. All lawns were established in the fall of 2012 on 3% hillside slope at the University of Maryland Paint Branch Turfgrass Facility. Each lawn treatment was replicated twice.   Prior to establishment, the soil in tall fescue+microclover plots was amended with 2 inches of yard waste compost (i.e., Leafgro). All plots were rototilled to a depth of 5 inches (one pass) as part of the seedbed preparation process. Five applications (April, June, Sept., Oct. and Nov.) of 0.7 lbs nitrogen per thousand square feet were made to tall fescue only lawns in 2013. The April application was made using urea. All other applications were made using sulfur coated urea.
Monitoring of runoff was limited to natural storm events with snowmelt events being excluded from data collection due to equipment limitations. From 1, April to 31, December 2013 there were six storm events that generated runoff. An equipment malfunction during one of the events preempted including this data the 2013 summary.
Cumulative runoff for the 5 storm events was 50% lower from the compost amended, non-fertilized tall fescue + microclover plots than from the well fertilized tall fescue plots that were not amended with compost prior to turf establishment. On average, 3.1% of the precipitation that occurred during the five storm events was lost as runoff from compost amended, Tall fescue + microclover lawns, whereas, 6.2% of precipitation was lost from the non-compost amended well-fertilized tall fescue lawn plots.
Increased shoot density is often associated with a decline in runoff from lawns. Preliminary shoot data collected in 2013 suggest that a tall fescue + microclover lawn, when established in a recently compost amended soil,  does not need to receive nitrogen fertilizer in the first year following establishment, in order to maintain  a shoot density that is comparable (if not greater) than that present in a well fertilized tall fescue lawn.

Shoot density data collected in 2013
Lawn Treatment  
Shoots (m2)
July
November
Fertilized Tall fescue
12,300
11,200
Tall fescue + Microclover in compost amended soil
19,000
20,600
Pr > F
0.16
0.14
Monitoring runoff from the edge of isolated field plots does not consider the  process of stormwater run-on into turf areas from impervious surfaces such as rooftops, sidewalks and driveways that occur in residential settings. As such, one should not interpret the results presented here as indicating the use of compost as a soil amendment, and the inclusion of microclover into a lawn seed mixture, will reduce residential stormwater runoff by 50%.   Actual reductions associated with the use of these two practices will depend on many factors including, but not limited, to those mentioned at the beginning of this blog. Nevertheless, the 2013 simulated home lawn data do indicate that the practices of amending soil with large amounts of compost, and including microclover as a component in the lawn seed mixture, will promote lawn characteristics that reduce stormwater losses from lawn areas. 

Monday, September 2, 2013

Update on Experiments from the University Park Site

Data collection is in progress for the 2013 growing season at the University Park site for Compost Amendment Study I (2 inch compost layer tilled into compacted loam soil) and Compost Amendment Study II (annual 1/4 inch compost surface application).  Ratings for spring green-up, quality, color, % ground cover, % clover cover, spring clipping yield assessments and nitrogen recovery have been collected through July, and plots are being prepared for summer clipping yield assessments and nitrogen recovery.  Microclover and tall fescue are tolerating the excessive summer heat and rains, and appear to be in excellent condition. 

Compost Study II
In Compost Amendment Study II, a ¼ layer of compost was applied to the turf surface in June.  Plots were aerated, compost was applied to the turf, and the area was sliced using a verticutting unit. A significant green-up response was noticed about 2 weeks after application.  Plots designated for the 1.0 lb nitrogen/1000 ft2 application were fertilized with polymer-coated urea (Lesco Poly-Plus; 39-0-0) in June.  As with Compost Amendment Study I, a noticeable green-up from the nitrogen application occurred in late June and July.  Microclover is the dominate species in all microclover/tall fescue plots, with clover cover ratings often exceeding 90%.

The microclover herbicide tolerance experiment received early May applications of isoxaben (Gallery 75 DF), bentazon (Basagran 4.0 L), pendimethalin (Pendulum 60 WDG), prodiamine (Barricade 65 WDG), dithiopyr (Dimension 1.0 EC), and Benefin (Balan 2.5 G) to determine the tolerance of microclover to preemergence herbicides. With the exception of isoxaben, no injury to clover was detected.  All rates of isoxaben cause minor injury to clover; but injury subsided and was no longer apparent by mid-June. In June, applications of 2,4-D Amine (3.8 L), 2,4-DB Amine (1.75 L), MCPA (3.7 L) were applied to determine the tolerance of microclover to postemeergence broadleaf herbicides.  Although some minor injury was detected following 2,4-D Amine applications, the clover recovered quickly and no permanent damage occurred. No visible
injury was detected with the other herbicides.

A project website was developed and launched in July, 2013 (http://plantscience.psu.edu/reduce-runoff). The site contains information on project background, objectives, methods, and goals/outcomes.  It also provides an outreach section with information on turf fertilizer recommendations, compost selection and application methods, liming, calibration of fertilizer spreaders, and examples of how to calculate fertilizer rates.  An events calendar and other sections (pages) will be added as more information becomes available. 


Friday, August 23, 2013

Lawn Establishment: A Reality Check from the Showcase Site




In my introductory turfgrass management course I always stress the importance of establishing cool season turfgrasses in the fall of the year. Seeding turfgrasses, such as tall fescue, in September or early October offers the advantages of near optimal soil temperature for seed germination, less weed and disease problems and greater retention of soil moisture during early seeding growth due to declining temperatures and day length. Implicit in my discussion of this topic is that one has a choice of when they will establish their lawn. Nothing could be further than the  truth for a Home Builder. Lawn establishment in new residential developments usually occurs in a relatively narrow window between the time the finished grade is created on a lot and the sale of the home. Lawn establishment has to occur during this window because sediment and erosion control plans almost always stipulate that soil stabilization on the lot needs to occur before transfer of the property to the new owner can take place.
In northern climates it is usually permissible to stabilize the soil for late fall to early spring property closings by placing straw or another type of erosion control material over the seed. For the remainder of the year though vegetative stabilization of the soil needs to occur in advance of transfer of the property. This means that cool season turfgrasses are sometimes seeded at the worst possible times of the year. This was clearly the case for the two residential lots that were seeded at the project showcase site. One lot was seeded on May 29, 2012 and the other on July 3   2012. Since neither lot possessed in ground irrigation, lawn establishment was completely dependent on natural rainfall. Rainfall during this time of year typically comes in form of thunderstorms and the summer of 2012 was no exception to this type of precipitation pattern. 
 The contractor placed down what I thought was an unusually thick layer of straw ( 3 inches uncompressed)  over the 95% tall fescue 5% microclover seed mixture that was broadcast in May . I was concerned that this much straw would inhibit the growth of microclover seedlings so I had the contractor cut the amount of straw  blown over the seedbed by about a third in the July seeded lot. After a couple of severe thunderstorms had passed through the area it became apparent why the contractor had placed so much straw down in May. Three inches uncompressed straw did a good job minimizing erosive losses and seed washout. Putting down two inches of straw was much less effective at minimizing washout, especially in areas where runoff tended to be limited to sheet flow only. Neither of two depths of straw was effective stopping erosive losses in areas of two yards where flow became channelized.  
                By October, the lawn seeded in May looked great. The July seeded lawn was still struggling to achieve full soil surface coverage due to the seed wash out that occurred over the summer.  Did straw thickness affect the establishment of the microclover? There was a fair amount of microclover present in the May seeded lawn by the end of summer. However, because of the seed washout that occurred in the July seeded lot, it was difficult to determine if microclover establishment was influenced by amount of straw placed in the seedbed. To get a better handled on the effect of straw cover on microclover establishment we will be conducting a study at the University of Maryland Paint Branch Turfgrass Research Facility this fall to see how the amount of straw cover affects the establishment of a tall fescue+ microclover lawn seed mixture. This study is one of the several microclover management studies that will be discussed at the 2013 University of Maryland Landscape Contractor Field Day. For those interesting in attending this field day, it will take place on Wednesday October 23, at the University of Maryland Paint Branch Turfgrass Research Facility, in College Park, Maryland.


Lawn  composition ten weeks after a 29 May seeding of a 95% tall fescue, 5% microclover lawn seed mixture.